Tip # 9: Quote to Claim Questions: Identify claim, focus on last line, paraphrase correct choice content, simplify main message, identify keywords, emotional language & evidence, eliminate easiest choices 1st, use confirmation strategies

.

Pre-task Strategies

1. Identify the Claim
   • Focus on the last line of the prompt (the claim).
   • Paraphrase it in your own words to ensure understanding.
   • Example: "Alexandra has a deep emotional connection to nature."
2. Predict What the Correct Quote Should Include
   • Keywords or ideas that align with the claim.
   • Emotional language (if the claim is about feelings).
   • Direct evidence, not just tangential descriptions.
3. Simplify Each Quote’s Main Message
   • Summarize each option in a few words.
   • Eliminate quotes that don’t directly support the claim.
4. Match the Best Fit
   • Avoid "keyword traps" (quotes that mention nature but don’t show emotion).
   • The best answer will fully illustrate the claim, not just touch on it.
5. Process of Elimination
   • Cross out options that are irrelevant or only partially related.
   • Compare remaining choices to see which is strongest.

Practice

Model Passages & Questions

Passage 1: "The Open Boat" by Stephen Crane
In this 1897 short story, Crane depicts the men in a lifeboat as being at the mercy of an indifferent and uncaring sea. The ocean is portrayed as neither cruel nor kind, but simply unconcerned with human survival:

Which quotation from "The Open Boat" most effectively illustrates the claim?

A) “The waves were nervously anxious to do something effective in the way of swamping boats.” 
B) “The ship itself was silent, save for the slow, rhythmic creaking of its timbers.” 
C) “The sea was a flat, endless gray, neither welcoming nor hostile, as though it had not noticed them at all.”
D) “The men cursed the ocean, shouting at it as if it could hear them, but it gave no reply.” 

Answer at end

Passage 2: "Self-Reliance" by Ralph Waldo Emerson

In this 1841 essay, Emerson argues that society discourages individuality, pressuring people to conform rather than think for themselves. He asserts that true greatness comes from rejecting external influences:

Which quotation from "Self-Reliance" most effectively illustrates the claim?

A) “A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophers and divines.” 
B) “Society everywhere is in conspiracy against the manhood of every one of its members.” 
C) “Trust thyself: every heart vibrates to that iron string.” 
D) “The voyage of the best ship is a zigzag line of a hundred tacks.” 

Answer at the end
​
Post-Task Assessments & Reflections

1. Self-Check Questions
   • Did I correctly identify the claim before reviewing the quotes?
   • Did I eliminate options that were only partially related?
   • Did I avoid being misled by "keyword traps"?
2. Common Pitfalls
   • Choosing a quote that mentions the topic but doesn’t illustrate the claim.
   • Overlooking subtle language (e.g., "indifferent" vs. "hostile").
   • Rushing and not simplifying each quote’s main idea.
3. Reflection
   • Practice paraphrasing claims to ensure comprehension.
   • Focus on direct evidence—the best answer won’t require interpretation.
   • Time management: Spend more time on the claim than the options.

Answer Key

Passage 1
Correct Answer: C (Directly illustrates the sea’s indifference.)

A) “The waves were nervously anxious to do something effective in the way of swamping boats.” [Personifies the sea as "anxious," suggesting intention—doesn’t match indifference.]
B) “The ship itself was silent, save for the slow, rhythmic creaking of its timbers.” [Neutral description, no focus on the sea’s indifference.]
C) “The sea was a flat, endless gray, neither welcoming nor hostile, as though it had not noticed them at all.” [Matches "indifferent and uncaring."]
D) “The men cursed the ocean, shouting at it as if it could hear them, but it gave no reply.” [Shows human frustration but not the sea’s indifference directly.]


Passage 2: 
Correct Answer: B (Explicitly describes society’s pressure against individuality.)

A) “A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophers and divines.” [Criticizes conformity but doesn’t show societal pressure.]
B) “Society everywhere is in conspiracy against the manhood of every one of its members.” [Directly states society suppresses individuality.]
C) “Trust thyself: every heart vibrates to that iron string.” [Focuses on self-trust, not societal pressure.]
D) “The voyage of the best ship is a zigzag line of a hundred tacks.” [Metaphor for life’s challenges, irrelevant to conformity.]